Florida insurers and old roofs have been locked in a fight for a decade. Premiums rise, carriers non-renew, and homeowners are told a 17-year-old roof makes the house uninsurable. Since December 2022, state law has narrowed what insurers can do — but not as much as many headlines suggested. Here is the practical picture.
What the 2022 law (SB 2-A) actually did
- A residential insurer generally cannot deny coverage or refuse renewal solely because of roof age if the roof is less than 15 years old, or is 15+ years old but inspected and found to have 5 or more years of useful life remaining and is in otherwise good condition.
- An insurer can still require a roof inspection before making that call, and a documented poor-condition roof can still be handled under the policy's terms.
- Insurers must offer a roof-deductible option in some situations, which can reduce premium in exchange for a bigger share of roof-loss risk on you.
The law is narrower than "they can never cancel me over my roof." Its protections turn on inspections and documentation — which means the homeowner's paperwork matters.
What this means if your roof is 12 years old
You are generally within the protected range. If a carrier cites age alone to non-renew, that is worth a complaint to the Department of Financial Services. Keep the roof well-maintained and photographed; condition is a permitted consideration, so a documented well-kept roof is your best defense.
What this means if your roof is 18 years old
You are in the inspection zone. An inspection finding 5+ years of remaining useful life, signed by a licensed inspector, is the document that protects you. Without it, a carrier can act on the roof's condition — and with an undocumented roof, the carrier's word tends to win. An inspection costs a few hundred dollars; a non-renewal or ACV-only roof schedule can cost tens of thousands at claim time.
Claims: replacement vs repair, and the ACV problem
Storm damage to an older roof triggers the second fight: the insurer may compute payment at actual cash value — replacement minus depreciation — leaving you a fraction of a new roof's cost. Whether you have replacement-cost coverage on the roof depends on your policy's declarations. Read our policy-reading guide before you need it, not after.
Before you sign anything for a "free roof inspection"
After any storm, door-knockers offering free roof inspections arrive within days. Some are legitimate; some manufacture damage claims or harvest signatures. You do not need their consent to get your own inspection. Hire or accept inspections from licensed, locally verifiable professionals — our roofing listings come from the DBPR register, and every record links to the state lookup.